Comments on: Tell us what you think of Peirs Morgan American Idol Judge

By: Ms MO

Ms MO — Fri, 17 Sep 2010 16:18:10 +0000

I would like to state that without a doubt the Winner only “W0N” because of sympathy! Yes he does have a voice that can entertain you, however, it has not been consistent. His last 2 performances were his only worthy performances ” it takes more than that to hold an audience “! Though I truly believe Jackie should have won, I also realize Fighting Gravity would actually be able to entertain all age groups, not to mention how unique their act is. When you are looking for “TOP SHOW QUALITY AS WELL AS SHOW STOPPERS” obviously Fighting Gravity,Jackie and Prince Poppycock would fit the bill! I also believe Sharon’s statement of her husband placed a $100 bet on Michael Grim, only influenced people to vote for him! Between Hurricane Katrina, his Grandparents, and the bet Grim won out of SYMPATHY!

I am still working on restoring my average home without any help! So, you see, there is still a lot of us struggling – but that should not effect the results of a TRUE TALENT SHOW TO REPRESENT AMERICA’S GOT TALENT!

Now that is said, I would like to know what has happened to the Black Ins. Salesman who sang Opera in the past as well as Kevin who also was from Ms, but he struggled working with “chickens”?

How do we get that answered?

Thanks,

Ms MO

By: Vivian Paulikonis

Vivian Paulikonis — Thu, 16 Sep 2010 02:18:28 +0000

Piers Morgan told it like it is. Prince Poppycock although talented, would not make a good US rep. I applauded Piers on Tuesday and was dissapointed that he felt like he needed to apologize on Wed. I simply cannot believe that a average singer like whatever the winners name is, was voted as the most talented. NO WAY !!!!! Fighting Gravity so talented and so different. Jackie, the best. I believe the votes were altered, the show is fixed, and I and most of the people I know, will never watch the show again.

By: john tillman

john tillman — Wed, 15 Sep 2010 03:30:44 +0000

Piers was extremely rude to buzz PRINCE POPPYCOCK in the final show 9-14-2010 he showed his english poppycock ASS!!! Prince P. showed he as always can sing & be not a joke but serious& MORE variety!! J. Evancho the week before showed her serious side a bit & this week so did P. Poppycock!! Prince P. is older and has a more limited time to be famous & I vote for him. I hope AMERICA votes as I will for PP. J. Evancho is my second choice…so sweet & so perfect!! PP has a more diverse show that is great for any town USA I wish he would come to Boise Idaho or Kauai!!

By: Patricia Anderson

Patricia Anderson — Fri, 11 Sep 2009 22:03:07 +0000

I am thoroughtly enjoying the show this although I miss Arcadian Broad & Pete Peterkin now.I adore Sharon Osburne, what a sweet heart. I know Piers ‘seems harsh’ but that his part isn’t it, it makes the show interesting. Besides i know that Simon redommended him for that part, with that in mind. Seems Simon’s everywhere. How ever I laove Simon because he’s honest and so is Piers, the Hoffmeister is cute but they need to stop portraying him as a lecherous person he’s truly compassionate and kind.Tricia in Seattle(Burien)

By: Ryan

Ryan — Tue, 10 Jun 2008 21:35:06 +0000

In the UK version of the show, Piers is one of the (if not, THE) nicest judge(s) on the show. It’s normally Simon Cowell who’s the nasty one.

By: peter messmer

peter messmer — Fri, 22 Feb 2008 01:23:28 +0000

Hello

Tonigth I had to feel ashamed as a european.
Peirs Morgan insulted an artist in a way that should NOT go by without consequences. If I where the artist I would sue him! In my homecountry a public insult like that would have serious consequences!
If Peirs Morgan does not IN PUBLIC regrets his behaviour and APPOLOGIZE then at least someone else at the program should do it.
I am sure Mr Hasselhoff could make you american´s proud if he would take this difficult task

I hope that despite my bad english I made clear what I said.

Regards
Peter Messmer